Sun 20 May 2012
listen this page

Observer variation in the evaluation and classification of severe central tarsal bone fractures in racing Greyhounds.

Hercock CA, Innes JF, McConnell F, Guilliard MJ, Ness MG, Hodson D, Young IS. Carol Hercock, BSc, The University of Liverpool, School of Veterinary Science, Liverpool, L69 7ZJ, United Kingdom, Phone: +44 151 794 4241, Fax: +44 151 4243, E-mail: C.A.Hercock@liverpool.ac.uk. VCOT 2011 24 3 215-22
Objectives: To determine observer agreement on radiographic evaluation of central tarsal bone (CTB) fractures and compare this with evaluation of the same fractures using computed tomography (CT). Methods: Radiographs and CT scans were obtained of the right tarsi from limbs of Greyhounds euthanatized after sustaining severe CTB fracture during racing. Four observers described and classified each fracture. Inter- and intra-observer agreements were calculated. Results: Inter-observer agreement was higher for assessment of fractures using CT. Several fractures assessed by radiography were misclassified as a less severe type. Intra-observer agreement for assessment and classification of CTB fractures via radiography versus CT was variable. Overall agreement among all four observers was higher for CT than radiography. Additionally, when identifying fractures of the adjacent tarsal bones, observer agreement was higher for CT than radiography. Clinical significance: Computed tomography improved observer ability to correctly evaluate CTB fracture and detect the degree of displacement and extent of any comminution. Identification of fractures of adjacent tarsal bones was also improved when tarsi were assessed using CT. These data suggest that treatment decisions based solely on radiographic assessment of CTB fractures may not produce the expected outcome.

Official newsletter

Stay informed with OrthoVetSuperSite Newsletter

Small Animals Poll Large Animals Poll

Jobs

OrthoVet Books

McILWRAITH
Diagnostic and surgical arthroscopy in the horse
3rd ed., 480 pages, 1409 ill., Elsevier, January 2006
List price: € 214,00
Sell price: € 182,00
MUIR
Advances in the canine cranial cruciate ligament
1st ed., 289 pages, 350 ill., John Wiley & Sons, September 2010
List price: € 119,00
Sell price: € 101,00
MONTAVON-VOSS-LANGLEY-HOBBS
Feline orthopedic surgery and muscoloskeletal disease
1st ed., 563 pages, 1200 ill., Elsevier, November 2009
List price: € 91,99
Sell price: € 78,00
MAY
Self-assessment colour review of equine orthopaedics and rheumatology
1st ed., 192 pages, 320 ill., Manson Publishing/The Veterinary Press, June 1998
List price: € 39,00
Sell price: € 33,00
HOULTON
BSAVA Manual of canine and feline musculoskeletal disorders
1st ed., 448 pages, 225 ill., BSAVA Publications, September 2006
List price: € 125,00
Sell price: € 106,00

Vet Events

Events

« May 2012 »
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031